Affordable Protein Powders: 5 Compared From Their Listings

Five widely sold protein powders compared from their listings, including whey and plant-based options, with label-reading tips. Not medical advice.

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. This post may contain affiliate links.
Best Affordable Protein Powder

Jump to our picks

Whey protein blend
Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Whey

A whey protein with 24 g of protein per serving, per the listing. Check the label for nutrition facts, sweeteners and other ingredients.

Check price on AmazonAdd to Amazon cart

We may earn a small referral fee

On this page
  1. In-depth Reviews
  2. Buying Guide
  3. Mixing notes: follow the label
  4. 💡 Editor’s Final Thoughts
  5. How to compare affordable protein powders
  6. What to watch for on the label
  7. Price and label checks
  8. See also

Protein powders vary in price, protein source, sweeteners and nutrition facts, and prices change often. This page compares five widely sold options from their listings. It is not medical advice and does not say that any protein powder suits a health goal or condition. The typical values below vary by flavor and size, so check the current label before you buy.

Whey protein blend
A whey protein with 24 g of protein per serving, per the listing.
Whey protein concentrate
A whey protein from Myprotein; the listing gives the protein per serving for the flavor and size. Check the current price on the listing.
Whey protein blend
A whey protein with 25 g of protein per serving, per the listing.

In-depth Reviews

Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Whey

Protein (typical)
24 g per serving (varies by flavor)
Calories (typical)
See the label
Protein source
Whey blend (isolate + concentrate + peptides)
Sweeteners
Varies by flavor; see the label
Mixing style
See the label
Notes: The listing describes a 100% whey protein with 24 g of protein per serving and BCAAs, sold in several flavors and sizes. This page has not tested mixing or taste. Flavors differ in sweeteners and nutrition facts, so check the label of the one you choose.
Points to note
  • 24 g of protein per serving, per the listing
  • Sold in many flavors and sizes
  • Check the label for sweeteners and other ingredients
Limits to know
  • Flavors differ in sweeteners and nutrition facts
  • Whey is a milk protein; check the label for allergens

MyProtein Impact Whey Protein

Protein (typical)
See the label (varies by flavor)
Calories (typical)
See the label
Protein source
Whey concentrate
Sweeteners
Varies by flavor; see the label
Texture
See the label
Notes: The listing describes a whey protein with 22 g of protein per serving in the unflavored version. This page has not tested mixing or taste. Flavors and sizes differ, so check the label.
Points to note
  • Check the current price on the listing
  • Sold in several flavors
  • Check the label for directions
Limits to know
  • Flavors differ in ingredients and nutrition facts
  • Whey is a milk protein; check the label for allergens

Dymatize Elite 100% Whey

Protein (typical)
25 g per serving (varies by flavor)
Calories (typical)
See the label
Protein source
Whey blend (concentrate + isolate)
Sweeteners
Varies by flavor
Best use
See the label
Notes: The listing describes a 100% whey protein with 25 g of protein per serving and 5.5 g of BCAAs. This page has not tested mixing or taste. Flavors differ, so check the label of the one you choose.
Points to note
  • 25 g of protein per serving, per the listing
  • Whey protein, per the listing
  • Check the label for directions
Limits to know
  • Flavors differ in ingredients and nutrition facts
  • Whey is a milk protein; check the label for allergens

Orgain Organic Plant-Based Protein Powder

Protein (typical)
21 g per serving
Calories (typical)
See the label
Protein source
Plant blend (varies by formula)
Diet notes
Plant-based, organic ingredients
Best mixing
See the label
Notes: The listing describes an organic vegan protein powder with 21 g of protein per serving and prebiotic fiber, with no added sugar or lactose, per the listing. This page has not tested taste or texture. Formulas differ by flavor, so check the label for the nutrition facts and ingredients.
Points to note
  • 21 g of protein per serving, per the listing
  • Plant-based, per the listing
  • Check the label for directions and allergens
Limits to know
  • Formulas differ by flavor; check the label
  • Check the current price on the listing

NOW Sports Whey Protein Isolate (Unflavored)

Protein (typical)
24 g per serving
Calories (typical)
See the label
Protein source
Whey isolate
Flavor
Unflavored
Best use
See the label
Notes: The listing describes an unflavored whey protein isolate with 24 g of protein per serving and BCAAs. This page has not tested taste or mixing. Check the label for the nutrition facts and ingredients.
Points to note
  • Unflavored whey protein isolate, per the listing
  • 24 g of protein per serving, per the listing
  • Check the label for ingredients
Limits to know
  • Whey is a milk protein; check the label for allergens
  • Size and price vary by listing

Buying Guide

If you want…Look for…Product in this guide
A widely sold whey blend Protein per serving, ingredients and the current price Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Whey
A whey concentrate Protein source, flavors and the current price MyProtein Impact Whey Protein
A whey blend Protein per serving and ingredients Dymatize Elite 100% Whey
A plant-based powder Protein source, allergens and ingredients Orgain Organic Plant-Based Protein Powder

Mixing notes: follow the label

Follow the label directions. The label gives directions for how much powder to use and what to mix it with. This page does not give amounts, and it has not tested taste or texture.

Check what you add. Anything you add to a shake changes its sugar, sodium and calorie content. Check those labels too, especially if a doctor has told you to limit sugar, salt or calories.

Clean your shaker as its maker directs. Shaker bottles come with their own care instructions; follow them.

💡 Editor’s Final Thoughts

Summary: Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Whey is the first product listed. This page compares five products from their listings and does not rank them for health or results. Check the current price and the label of each. MyProtein Impact Whey Protein is a whey concentrate, and Orgain Organic Plant-Based Protein Powder is a plant-based option.

How to compare affordable protein powders

One way to compare value is to look at cost per serving, then compare it with the protein per serving and the ingredient list.

  • Start with servings per container, not tub size, because scoop sizes differ.
  • Check protein density: compare grams of protein with calories per serving on each label.
  • Decide how you will use it: the label gives directions for what to mix the powder with.
  • Plan for repeat purchases: check the current price and size on the listing.

What to watch for on the label

A few label details are worth checking before you buy.

Protein type: whey concentrate vs isolate vs plant blends

Whey concentrate is a milk protein; the label lists the protein type and allergens. Whey isolate is also a milk protein, processed differently; this page does not say that either suits any person better. Plant-based blends are made from plant proteins; check the label for the protein source, allergens and ingredients.

Sweeteners and thickeners

Protein powders use different sweeteners and thickeners, and the ingredient list shows which. If a product upsets your stomach, stop using it and ask a doctor or dietitian.

Allergens and ingredients

Check the label for milk, soy and other allergens. If you have a food allergy, lactose intolerance or another health condition, ask a doctor or dietitian before using a protein powder.

Flavors and sizes

Nutrition facts and ingredients differ between flavors and sizes of the same product, so check the label of the exact one you choose.

Price and label checks

A lower price does not tell you what is in the tub. Compare the ingredient lists and the nutrition facts, not only the price.

If you are comparing products, start with the label and the ingredient list. This page does not say that any powder supports fullness, training or weight goals.

See also

For related guides, see kitchen cleaners and work-bag essentials.

Frequently Asked Questions ▾

Is whey protein always the best value?

Price depends on the product, size and sale at the time, so check the current price and the protein per serving. This page does not say that one protein type is better for any person. If a product upsets your stomach, stop using it and ask a doctor or dietitian.

Can I tell from a listing how a powder will taste?

Not reliably. This page has not tested taste, and flavors differ between products. Read the ingredient list and the flavor description on the listing.

How much protein powder should I use?

The label gives the serving size, and this page does not recommend amounts or a routine. How much protein is right for you depends on your health, age and diet, so ask a doctor or dietitian.

Which protein is right if I am lactose intolerant?

This page cannot say. Whey products are made from milk, and plant-based powders are not. Check each label for allergens and lactose, and ask a doctor or dietitian if you have lactose intolerance or a milk allergy.

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases made through links on our site.

Before you use any of these

Follow the directions on the label, and if you have side effects, stop using the product and contact your health care provider. Many supplements have not been tested in pregnant women, nursing mothers or children, and some can interact with medicines or matter before surgery, so check with a doctor or pharmacist first.

Independent testing programs such as USP and NSF publish their own standards. If a testing mark matters to you, look up the exact product in the program's own listing rather than relying on a label or a web page.

If you have kidney disease or have been told to limit protein, ask your doctor or a dietitian before using a protein powder.

Sources and further reading: FDA: information for consumers on using dietary supplements; NCCIH: using dietary supplements wisely; USP; NSF.