Provides a lightweight, non-sticky tint that hydrates dry lips while lasting through daily wear.
We may earn a small referral fee
If your lips run dry no matter the season, Rare Beauty’s Soft Pinch Tinted Lip Oil promises a plush, non-sticky wash of color that settles into a soft, lived-in stain. I tested it through long workdays and coffee runs to see whether comfort and color can really coexist for dry lips.
Rare Beauty’s Soft Pinch Tinted Lip Oil sits in an increasingly crowded category, yet it promises something specific that dry-lipped shoppers crave: a cushiony, non-sticky feel with color that outlasts the shine. After weeks of wearing it on parched, flaky lips in real life, here is the straightforward verdict on texture, hydration, longevity, and how to make it look its best.
Overview
Soft Pinch Tinted Lip Oil is a gel-to-oil lip tint. It goes on like a springy jelly, turns slippy like an oil as you spread it, then settles into a sheer to medium stain with a soft sheen. The shine wears down within a couple of hours, but the color hangs on for much longer, especially in the deeper shades. The feel is light, cushiony, and not sticky. It is designed for quick, easy color that feels comfortable while you wear it and leaves a tint behind once the emollients fade.
The tube is compact and easy to grip, and the plush, angled doe-foot lays down an even coat without flooding the lip line. There is no minty tingle. Scent is very faint and sweet to neutral, and there is no noticeable flavor. Price falls in the mid-range for a prestige lip oil, and shade names mirror favorites from the Soft Pinch blush family, from everyday nudes to brighter pinks and berries.
Important to know: this is not a heavy treatment oil. It offers light to medium moisturization with a stain. If your lips are very dry, you will likely want a balm under or over it. Think of it as comfortable color with a gentle conditioning feel, not a repair mask.
Who it’s for
This lip oil is a great fit if you:
- Want sheer to medium color that looks lived-in rather than sharply lined
- Dislike sticky gloss but still want a cushy, juicy look
- Prefer low-fuss makeup that you can swipe on without a mirror
- Like a tint that survives coffee and light meals without feeling dry while it’s on
It may not be ideal if you:
- Need intensive repair for cracked lips and heavy flaking
- Expect glassy, high-lacquer shine for several hours
- Want full-coverage, opaque color that completely masks your natural lip tone
How it feels and performs
Texture and application
On first swipe, the formula feels like a bouncy gel that melts into a thin, silky oil. The doe-foot applicator is generously sized and softly flexible, which helps spread a thin layer even on textured lips. The slip is real, but it does not run into lip lines as easily as traditional gloss. One thin coat gives a sheer wash. A second coat, after a short wait, builds to light-medium coverage.
Finish and color shift
The initial finish is dewy and juicy for about 60 to 90 seconds, then it settles to a soft gloss. As the emollients absorb or wear off, the color deepens slightly into a stain. Plan for a small shift: what you see immediately after application is a touch lighter than the stain that remains 10 minutes later. The effect is most noticeable in brighter and deeper shades.
Comfort and hydration on dry lips
Comfort is the standout. It never feels heavy or tacky, and there is no tightening as it sets. Hydration is light to medium. While the oil is present, lips feel cushioned and smooth. Once the shine fades, lips still feel soft, but very dry lips may want a quick balm tap for extra slip. If you have peeling, the stain can catch slightly on flakes, so prep helps a lot.
Longevity and wear pattern
Shine: about 1 to 2 hours, depending on talking, sipping, and weather. Stain: 4 to 6 hours on average, with deeper shades lasting longer and lighter nudes fading sooner. It wears evenly if you apply thin layers. Overapplying can cause a darker line at the inner rim of the lips as the color concentrates there. The formula transfers as a gloss to cups and napkins, but the tint underneath keeps lips looking colored after transfer.
Feathering, lines, and sensitivity
Feathering is minimal because the initial gel texture keeps the product where you put it. If you have pronounced vertical lip lines, a clear or tone-matching lip liner will keep edges clean. There is no cooling or plumping ingredient that might irritate sensitive lips, and the scent is barely there. Most users should find it agreeable from a sensitivity standpoint.
Shades and undertones
The lineup includes wearable nudes, rosy neutrals, peaches, and deeper berries. General guidance:
- Fair to light skin: try soft pinks and peachy nudes that will not overwhelm once they stain
- Medium to tan: mauves, rosewoods, and warm corals give a healthy, just-bitten look
- Deep skin: richer berries and brown-roses show up well and leave the longest-lasting tint
If you love Rare Beauty’s Soft Pinch liquid blush, choose the coordinating lip oil shade name for an easy monochrome look. The stain tends to deepen by a half tone, so if you are between two, pick the lighter one for a softer everyday lip.
How it compares to gloss, balm, and traditional stains
Compared with a classic gloss, this feels lighter with less cling. Compared with a balm, it is more colorful yet less nourishing over long stretches. Compared with a classic water-based lip stain, it feels far more comfortable and forgiving on dry patches, with a softer, more blurred look rather than a sharp marker-like edge. It is a true middle ground for people who want color that lasts through coffee without sacrificing comfort.
How to use for best results
Prep makes a visible difference
- Buff away flakes with a gentle lip exfoliator or a damp washcloth
- Add a thin layer of a plain, non-waxy balm and let it sit 5 to 10 minutes, then blot
This gives the oil a smooth surface so the stain sets evenly rather than grabbing onto dry spots.
Application that lasts and looks even
- Outline lightly with a clear or nude lip liner if your lip line is soft or prone to feathering
- Swipe on a thin coat, focusing on the center, then press lips together to spread
- Wait 60 to 90 seconds for the gel-to-oil phase to settle
- Add a second thin coat for more impact, then gently blot the inner rim to prevent a line
- Optional: tap a small amount of balm over the top once the color sets if your lips are very dry
During the day
Reapply a single thin coat after lunch to refresh shine and evenness. If lips feel parched before reapplying, add a tiny balm tap first, then the lip oil. The formula plays well with most lip liners and clear glosses. It also layers neatly over satin lipsticks to revive color without adding stickiness.
Removal
Because the product leaves a tint, remove with an oil-based makeup remover or massage a rich balm onto lips and wipe with a soft cloth. This avoids aggressive rubbing that can aggravate dryness.
Pros and cons
- Comfortable, non-sticky feel that dry lips can tolerate for hours
- Sheer to medium color that settles into a soft, even stain
- Plush applicator and gel texture make for tidy, quick application
- Minimal feathering compared to traditional gloss
- Subtle or no scent and no flavor, friendly for sensitive noses
- Builds from casual tint to more polished lip with a second coat
- Not a heavy-duty moisturizer, so very dry lips may still want balm
- Shine fades within a couple of hours, which some users may find too quick
- Stain can catch on flakes if you skip prep
- Overapplication can leave a darker inner rim line as it wears
Final verdict
If you are chasing comfy color that does not make dry lips feel tighter as the day goes on, Rare Beauty Soft Pinch Tinted Lip Oil delivers. It gives that cushiony, plush look without stickiness, and the tint keeps you looking fresh even after the shine transfers to your mug or your coffee cup. Hydration is light to medium, so it will not replace a treatment balm, but it does not pretend to. With simple prep and thin layers, the finish is smooth, flattering, and flexible from workday to weekend. Reach for lighter shades when you want an easy, everyday lip, and choose the deeper tones when you want stain power that still feels soft.
See also
If your priority is comfort above all else, you may want to compare this to the hydrating formulas in our guide to the Best Lipstick for Dry Lips. And if you are debating categories, our breakdown of Lip Oil vs Lip Gloss: Which One Actually Feels Better Long Term explains how each wears on parched lips.
For shade shopping by skin tone and routine building, browse our picks for everyday and statement colors in Best Lipsticks for Brown Skin, Everyday To Bold, then round out a soft-focus base with options from Best Tinted Moisturizers With SPF and a dewy cheek from Best Cream Blushes for Dry or Mature Skin.
FAQ
Does Rare Beauty Soft Pinch Tinted Lip Oil actually hydrate dry lips or just add shine?
It provides light to medium hydration while the oils are on the lips, so it feels cushioned and comfortable. Once the shine fades, lips still feel soft but not deeply conditioned. If your lips are very dry, pair it with a thin layer of balm underneath or tap a bit of balm over the stain for extra slip.
How long does the color last and does it leave a stain?
The glossy finish lasts about 1 to 2 hours, depending on talking and sipping. The color sets into a soft stain that can last 4 to 6 hours, longer with deeper shades. Expect some transfer of the initial shine to mugs or napkins, but the tint underneath remains.
What are the best shades if I want a natural everyday lip that does not turn too dark?
Choose lighter nudes, peaches, and soft pinks if you want a subtle everyday look. Because the color deepens slightly as it stains, selecting a shade that is a touch lighter than your target result often works best for a natural finish.
Will it emphasize flakes or bleed into fine lines?
The gel-to-oil texture minimizes feathering compared with a traditional gloss, but flakes can catch the stain. Gently exfoliate and blot a thin layer of balm first, then apply one or two thin coats. If your lip line is prone to bleeding, a clear or tone-matching liner will keep the edges tidy.
Can I layer it with other lip products?
Yes. It layers well over lip balm, pairs with a nude liner for extra definition, and can refresh a fading satin lipstick without adding stickiness. If you plan to add a clear gloss on top, let the tint set for a minute first to avoid sliding.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases made through links on our site.