Best Toys for Labs: Durable, Engaging Picks That Can Keep Up

Labrador Retrievers are smart, energetic, and powerful chewers, which makes toy shopping tricky. Pick well and toys will keep your Lab busy, protect your furniture, and give you an easy way to burn off extra energy. Pick poorly and you are left with shredded rubber, potential choking hazards, and a disappointed dog.

This guide focuses on durable, safe toys that work for real Labs in real homes. You will find top picks for fetch, chewing, and mental stimulation, with clear guidance on which toys fit your dog’s age, play style, and energy level.

Quick picks

• Kong Classic Dog Toy – Best overall for power chewers and stuffing. A nearly indestructible rubber cone you can stuff with food or treats to keep your Lab busy for long stretches.
• Chuckit! Ultra Ball – Best fetch ball for water and land. High-bounce, durable rubber balls that are easy to spot, gentle on teeth, and fit most ball launchers for long-distance play.
• Outward Hound Hide-A-Squirrel Puzzle Toy – Best for mental stimulation indoors. A soft puzzle log with squeaky squirrels that taps into your Lab’s natural hunting instincts without being too hard on teeth.
• West Paw Zogoflex Bumi Tug Toy – Best for interactive tug and fetch. A stretchy S-shaped tug toy that is tough but has enough give to be comfortable for both you and your dog.
• Nylabone Power Chew Flavored Dog Bone – Best for long-lasting solo chewing. A hard nylon bone in different sizes and flavors that satisfies serious chewers and helps reduce destructive chewing around the house.

In-depth reviews

Kong Classic Dog Toy review

The Kong Classic is a staple for Lab owners because it combines durability, enrichment, and versatility in one simple toy. Made from thick natural rubber, it stands up well to most power chewers, especially if you size up for adult Labs. Its hollow center lets you stuff kibble, peanut butter, or frozen mixtures so your dog works for their reward instead of inhaling it in seconds.

This toy shines for crate training, managing separation anxiety, and rainy-day boredom. It bounces unpredictably, which keeps fetch interesting without being too hard on teeth. The main drawbacks are that ultra-aggressive chewers can eventually break it down, and cleaning inside the cavity takes a bit of effort, especially after sticky fillings.

Choose the Kong Classic if you want a daily go-to toy that can be used for both chewing and feeding. Compared with the Nylabone Power Chew, the Kong is softer and safer for long sessions, but the Nylabone lasts longer for dogs that live to gnaw. If you only buy one toy for your Lab, this is the most versatile choice.

Chuckit! Ultra Ball review

The Chuckit! Ultra Ball is designed for Labs that live for fetch. Its thick rubber construction is more durable than a tennis ball and resists punctures better than most standard dog balls, while still having some flex. The bright color makes it easy to spot, and it floats well, which is perfect for water-loving Labs at the lake or pool.

Unlike tennis balls, this ball does not have abrasive fuzz that can wear down your dog’s teeth over time. It fits most Chuckit-style launchers for long throws that actually tire your Lab out. The potential downside is that determined chewers can eventually split the ball if they are allowed to lie down and gnaw instead of staying focused on fetch.

Pick the Chuckit! Ultra Ball if your Lab is a fetch addict who needs serious exercise. Compared with the Kong Classic, the Chuckit is better for high-intensity games and swimming sessions, while the Kong is better as a chew-and-stuff toy for quiet times.

Outward Hound Hide-A-Squirrel Puzzle Toy review

The Outward Hound Hide-A-Squirrel gives your Lab a mental workout without requiring a huge backyard. The plush log holds several squeaky squirrel toys that your dog must sniff out and pull free, which taps into their natural hunting and retrieving instincts. Because it is soft, it is gentler on teeth and especially nice for puppies and older Labs.

This toy is excellent for rainy days, apartment living, or times when your dog cannot do intense running but still needs a challenge. The main drawback is durability. Strong Labs that like to shred plush toys can tear up the squirrels if they are left unsupervised, so it works best as an interactive or supervised puzzle rather than an all-day chew toy.

Choose Hide-A-Squirrel if your Lab gets bored easily or seems underchallenged with basic fetch. Compared with the Kong Classic or Nylabone Power Chew, this toy focuses on brain work more than jaw work. Combine it with a tougher chew toy to cover both mental and physical needs.

West Paw Zogoflex Bumi Tug Toy review

The West Paw Zogoflex Bumi is a flexible S-shaped toy that shines in tug-of-war and fetch. The material is tough enough for most Labs but has enough stretch to be comfortable for both your hands and your dog’s mouth. Its curved shape makes it easy for two dogs to grab opposite ends, which is great if you have a multi-dog household.

This toy floats and is brightly colored, so it doubles as a fun fetch toy at the park or in the water. The biggest downside is that heavy solo chewers may eventually damage it if they are left alone to gnaw, since it is designed more for interactive play than for extended chewing sessions.

Choose the Bumi if your Lab loves playing tug and you want a safer alternative to old rope toys that unravel. Compared with the Chuckit! Ultra Ball, the Bumi is better for close-up games and bonding, while the ball is better for distance and speed. Pairing both gives you great options for different kinds of exercise.

Nylabone Power Chew Flavored Dog Bone review

The Nylabone Power Chew line is built for Labs that seem determined to destroy every toy they meet. These hard nylon bones come in multiple sizes and flavors, which can make them more appealing than plain rubber. They are designed to slowly wear down into tiny rice-sized shavings rather than breaking into large chunks.

For many owners, the biggest benefit is redirecting destructive chewing away from shoes, furniture, and baseboards. These bones can last weeks or even months, especially if you cycle a few different ones. The main drawbacks are that they are very hard, which may not suit dogs with dental issues, and the plastic texture is less forgiving than rubber, so they work best for adult dogs with healthy teeth.

Go with a Nylabone Power Chew if your Lab lies down specifically to chew for long stretches. Compared with the Kong Classic, the Nylabone provides a longer-lasting, more intense chew experience, while the Kong offers more enrichment through stuffing and play.

How to choose the right toy for your Lab

Start with your Lab’s age and life stage. Puppies need softer toys and puppy-safe rubber that will not damage growing teeth, while seniors often prefer gentle, easy-to-grip toys. Adult Labs with healthy mouths can usually handle tougher rubber and nylon options.

Next, match toys to your dog’s play style. Fetch-obsessed Labs do best with balls, flying toys, and floating fetch toys. Chewers need sturdy bones and rubber toys like the Kong. Problem-solvers and easily bored dogs benefit from puzzle toys, snuffle mats, or toys that release food gradually.

Size matters too. Labs typically need large or extra-large toys so they cannot swallow them whole. When in doubt, size up, especially with balls and chew bones. Always check the manufacturer’s weight and size guidelines for your dog’s range.

Finally, build a small rotation of different toy types. A good mix might include one tough chew toy, one fetch toy, and one puzzle or stuffable toy. Rotating these every few days keeps each toy “new” in your Lab’s eyes and extends their useful life.

Safety tips for Lab playtime

Labs are enthusiastic players, which means toy safety should always be on your radar. Inspect toys frequently for tears, deep cracks, missing pieces, or loose stuffing. If you can pull off pieces with your fingers or see threads hanging out, retire the toy before your dog swallows something.

Avoid very small balls, brittle plastic toys, and cooked bones that can splinter. Tennis balls are fine for light fetch, but the fuzzy surface can wear down teeth over years of constant chewing, so do not let your dog sit and grind them. For aggressive chewers, prioritize solid rubber or chew toys labeled for power chewers, and never leave soft toys unsupervised.

Supervision is especially important when introducing any new toy. Watch how your Lab interacts with it for the first few sessions. If you see frantic shredding or attempts to swallow large pieces instead of chewing, that toy is not a good fit, no matter how highly it is rated.

Finally, keep playtime controlled and positive. For tug-of-war, teach a cue such as “drop it” or “give” and reward your Lab for releasing the toy. This helps prevent accidental nips and gives you an easy way to end games before your dog becomes overstimulated.

Final thoughts

The best toys for Labs are tough, engaging, and matched to your dog’s specific play style. For most families, starting with a Kong Classic for stuffing, a Chuckit! Ultra Ball for fetch, and a Nylabone Power Chew for serious chewing covers the core needs very well.

From there, add a puzzle toy like Hide-A-Squirrel for rainy-day brain work and a tug toy like the West Paw Bumi for interactive play and bonding. Pay attention to how your Lab actually uses each toy, rotate them often, and retire anything that shows real wear. With a small, well-chosen set, you can keep your Lab happy, stimulated, and safely entertained for years.

See also

If you are curious about your Lab’s breed mix and inherited health risks, our Embark dog DNA test review explains how at-home genetic testing can help you plan smarter care.

• In-depth Litter-Robot 4 self-cleaning litter box review for multi-pet homes that also include cats

FAQ

How many toys should a Lab have?

Most Labs do well with 5 to 10 toys in total, but only a few available at any one time. Keep two or three out for daily use and store the rest, then rotate toys every few days so they stay interesting without cluttering your space.

What toys are unsafe for Labs?

Toys that are too small, easy to shred, or made from brittle plastic are risky for Labs. Avoid cooked bones, toys with glued-on parts, and any ball small enough to lodge in your dog’s throat. If a toy feels flimsy in your hands, it probably will not stand up to a Lab.

How do I stop my Lab from destroying every toy?

Choose toys labeled for power chewers, like thick rubber and heavy-duty nylon, and avoid plush toys for solo play. Limit access to softer toys to supervised sessions and redirect your dog to an appropriate chew when they start shredding. Rotating toys and adding puzzle feeders can also reduce frustration that leads to destructive chewing.

Are squeaky toys safe for Labs?

Squeaky toys can be safe if you supervise closely and choose sturdy designs. Many Labs love the squeak so much that they work hard to remove it, which can turn the squeaker into a choking hazard. If your dog fixates on destroying squeakers, reserve these toys for short, supervised play and remove them if the fabric tears.

How often should I replace my Lab’s toys?

Inspect toys weekly and replace them as soon as they show significant cracks, missing chunks, or loose stuffing. Power chewers may need new toys every month or two, while gentle players can keep the same toys for much longer. When in doubt, err on the side of caution and retire questionable toys.

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases made through links on our site.