Softens fine lines and crepey skin overnight while hydrating without heavy residue or migrating into the eyes.
We may earn a small referral fee
Trying to pick an eye cream at Target is easy to overthink, especially when your goals are specific like fewer fine lines, less puffiness, or makeup that stops creasing. These picks narrow it down to what actually performs and who each one fits.
In-depth Reviews
Olay Eyes Retinol 24 Night Eye Cream
- Consistent smoothing with steady use
- Moisturizes without feeling heavy
- Works well as a simple nighttime eye step
- Can be drying if you overuse it early on
- Not the fastest option for morning puffiness
CeraVe Eye Repair Cream
- Reliable hydration that lasts through the day
- Plays nicely under concealer
- Comfortable for daily use even with sensitive routines
- Results are more about hydration than dramatic lifting
- Deep lines may need a retinoid option
e.l.f. Holy Hydration! Eye Cream
- Great value for everyday hydration
- Helps concealer sit more smoothly
- Easy to use morning and night
- Not a targeted fix for stubborn dark circles
- May be too light for very dry, winter skin
Neutrogena Rapid Wrinkle Repair Retinol Eye Cream
- Strong option for texture and fine lines
- Can improve how makeup wears over time
- Good step-up if gentle retinol is not enough
- Higher chance of dryness or sensitivity
- Needs careful spacing with other actives
La Roche-Posay Toleriane Dermallergo Eye Cream
- Very comfortable for easily irritated skin
- Reduces the urge to rub from dryness and tightness
- Layers well with simple routines
- Not a fast-acting de-puffing product
- Wrinkle results are mostly from hydration, not strong actives
Buying Guide
Quick Routine Fixes That Make Any Eye Cream Work Better
Use less product than you think. Most eye cream problems, including pilling, stinging, and migration into the eyes, come from over-applying. Aim for a tiny dot per eye, warm it between ring fingers, then tap along the orbital bone (the bony rim around the eye) instead of putting it right under the lashes.
Give it time to set before makeup. If you apply eye cream and immediately go in with sunscreen and concealer, you are practically guaranteeing slip and creasing. Wait a couple minutes, then press (do not rub) a thin layer of sunscreen around the area. For concealer, start with less and build only where you need coverage.
Separate “treatment nights” from “recovery nights.” Retinol eye creams can be effective, but the under-eye is not the place to stack multiple strong actives. On retinol nights, keep the rest of your routine gentle. On off nights, use a barrier-supporting eye cream and focus on hydration. This alternating rhythm is often what gets you results without the stop-and-start cycle of irritation.
💡 Editor’s Final Thoughts
Final verdict: If you want one Target eye cream that hits the widest range of concerns without getting complicated, Olay Eyes Retinol 24 Night Eye Cream is the top pick for its consistent smoothing and user-friendly feel. If you are easily irritated, swap to La Roche-Posay Toleriane Dermallergo Eye Cream and focus on comfort first, then add actives later.
See also
For more targeted de-puffing options, start with eye creams for puffiness and bags, and if discoloration is the bigger issue, compare brighteners in the best vitamin C eye creams.
- Eye creams with peptides worth buying
- Skyn ICELAND Hydro Cool under-eye gel review
- Best Ulta eye creams guide
Frequently Asked Questions ▾
How do I start a retinol eye cream without getting dry or irritated?
Start slowly and keep placement conservative. Use a tiny amount (think a pinhead per eye) and tap it along the orbital bone, not right up to the lash line. Begin 2 to 3 nights per week, then increase only if your skin stays comfortable.
If you tend to get dry, apply a simple moisturizer first, then your retinol eye cream on top, or “sandwich” it between two thin layers of moisturizer. If stinging lasts more than a few minutes, scale back frequency or switch to a gentler, non-retinol option.
Can I use an eye cream under concealer without pilling?
Yes, but timing and amount matter more than the specific brand. Use the smallest amount that gives slip, then wait 2 to 3 minutes before sunscreen and makeup so the product can set. If your concealer still pills, you are usually using too much eye cream or layering too many active serums underneath.
Gel textures generally behave best under makeup, while richer creams can be better at night. If you love a richer formula, keep it as your PM eye cream and use a lighter layer (or a gel) in the morning.
Is a dedicated eye cream actually necessary, or can I use face moisturizer?
For many people, a bland, fragrance-free face moisturizer is perfectly fine around the eyes, especially if dryness is your only issue. Where eye creams earn their keep is when they are formulated to be comfortable in a delicate area while still delivering targeted actives like retinol, niacinamide, or ceramides, and when they play well under makeup.
If your current moisturizer stings, migrates into your eyes, or never fully absorbs before concealer, a dedicated eye formula can be an easy upgrade.
How long does it take to see results from an eye cream?
Hydration and smoothing can look better fast, often within a few days, because plumper skin reflects light more evenly. Puffiness can improve quickly too if your formula includes de-puffing ingredients and you are consistent with sleep and salt intake.
For fine lines and texture changes from retinoids, plan on 6 to 12 weeks of consistent use. Dark circles are trickier because they can be caused by pigmentation, shadowing from volume loss, or visible blood vessels. In those cases, an eye cream may improve the look, but it may not fully “erase” the issue.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases made through links on our site.