Gives defined, buildable lashes that resist smudging and under-eye transfer in hot, humid conditions.
We may earn a small referral fee
I can do my makeup in air conditioning and feel like my lashes are finally behaving, then step outside into thick, wet air and suddenly I have a faint gray shadow under my eyes that makes me look more tired than I am. It is the kind of smudge that does not show up in your mirror at home, only when you catch yourself in daylight and want to wipe your whole face and start over. The relief is finding a mascara that stays put through sweat and humidity, but still comes off clean at night, so I am not tugging at my lashes and risking breakage.
In-depth Reviews
Caliray Come Hell or High Water Mascara
- Very resistant to smudging and transfer
- Buildable definition without heavy stiffness
- Wears evenly with minimal flaking
- Not the most dramatic volume on its own
- Needs warm water technique for the easiest removal
Kiss Me Heroine Make Long and Curl Mascara Super Waterproof
- Exceptional staying power in heat and humidity
- Helps lashes stay lifted longer
- Minimal smudging even with watery eyes
- Removal takes more effort than most
- Can feel drier if you layer too many coats
Thrive Causemetics Liquid Lash Extensions Mascara
- Strong lengthening effect with low transfer risk
- Comfortable wear that stays flexible
- Removes cleanly without harsh rubbing
- Volume is more natural than dramatic
- Can clump if you keep layering after it sets
Tower 28 MakeWaves Mascara
- Low-smudge wear for watery or sensitive eyes
- Easy, clean removal with warm water
- Buildable without feeling heavy
- Not the boldest for maximum drama
- Needs a steady hand to avoid over-applying at the tips
Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Waterproof Mascara
- Great performance for the price
- Helps keep lashes lifted in damp heat
- Long-wearing with minimal midday fallout
- Takes more effort to remove than tubing formulas
- Can feel stiff if you over-layer
Buying Guide
Humidity-Proof Lash Prep: The 5-Minute Routine That Matters More Than the Mascara
Start with a clean, set base. In humidity, the biggest enemy is usually slip: skincare, sunscreen, and natural oils mixing together and breaking down pigment. Before mascara, lightly blot your lids and under-eyes with tissue or a blotting paper, then set with a thin veil of translucent powder. If you use eye cream, keep it on the orbital bone, not right up to the lash line.
Use less product than you think. Thick coats stay tacky longer, and tacky mascara is what stamps onto skin when you blink in damp air. Wipe excess off the wand, apply one controlled coat, then let it set before you add another. A quick comb-through with a clean spoolie removes wet clumps that would otherwise flake later.
Place product strategically. For humidity days, I like focusing mascara from mid-lash to the tips, with just a touch at the roots. It keeps the look lifted but reduces the chance of transfer onto the lid. If lower lashes always smudge, either use a tubing formula there or skip them entirely and add definition with a soft tightline instead.
💡 Editor’s Final Thoughts
Final Verdict: If you want the easiest, most reliable “set it and forget it” wear in humid weather, Caliray Come Hell or High Water is my top pick because it stays clean through moisture without feeling crunchy. For maximum stay-put power (think sweat, beach days, and outdoor events), Heroine Make Long and Curl Super Waterproof is the toughest option here, just plan on an oil-based remover.
See also
If humidity always leads to transfer, start with tubing mascaras for smudge-free long days, and pair it with our guide to mascaras for oily eyelids if your lids get slick by noon.
- Mascaras that actually hold a curl
- Tower 28 MakeWaves tubing mascara review
- Caliray Come Hell or High Water mascara review
Frequently Asked Questions ▾
What works better in humidity: waterproof or tubing mascara?
It depends on your main issue. If you get under-eye smudges or transfer from oily lids, tubing formulas usually win because they form little “sleeves” that are less likely to melt and migrate. If your problem is lashes falling flat from heat and sweat, a true waterproof formula often holds curl better, but it can be harder to remove.
How do I remove humidity-proof mascara without losing lashes?
For tubing mascara, use warm water and gentle pressure, then slide the tubes off with your fingertips. For waterproof formulas, saturate a cotton pad with a cleansing oil or balm, press it to the lashes for a full minute, then wipe down gently. Rubbing back and forth is what causes most breakage, especially when lashes are already a little dry.
Why does my mascara still smudge even when it says “waterproof”?
Waterproof mainly means it resists water, not skin oils. In humid weather, a mix of sweat and oil can break down certain formulas and cause transfer, especially if your under-eye area is moisturized or your sunscreen creeps upward. A thin layer of translucent powder under the eyes and a tubing formula on the lower lashes can make a bigger difference than going more waterproof.
Can I layer a tubing mascara over a waterproof one?
You can, but it is finicky. Waterproof as a base can help hold curl, then a tubing coat can add smudge resistance, but only if the first layer is very thin and fully set. If you notice clumping or flaking, switch the order or keep it simple with one formula and focus on better prep.
What is the easiest way to stop mascara from melting onto my brow bone?
Keep the mascara off your upper lash roots as much as possible and concentrate product from mid-lash to the tips. Also, make sure your eyelid primer or concealer is set, even a little tackiness can grab pigment and move it around when you sweat. A clean spoolie comb-through at the end removes excess that would otherwise transfer.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases made through links on our site.