Gives polished length and separation that lasts; apply on dry, set lids to reduce transfer.
We may earn a small referral fee
You want a clean mascara that builds pretty lashes and still looks fresh at the end of the day. These picks focus on wear, definition, and removal, without the crunchy, flaky feel some cleaner formulas can have.
In-depth Reviews
ILIA Limitless Lash Mascara
- Great separation with a “your lashes but better” finish
- Builds without getting crunchy
- Comfortable for all-day wear
- May transfer on very oily lids
- Not the boldest volume if you want dramatic lashes
Kosas The Big Clean Mascara
- Quick payoff for fuller-looking lashes
- Builds well without getting spiky
- Comfortable, not overly stiff
- Can smudge on oily lids
- Can look heavy if you over-layer on fine lashes
Tower 28 MakeWaves Mascara
- Lightweight feel with low-fallout wear
- Pretty lift and separation for everyday
- Layers well if you keep it light
- Not the most dramatic volume
- May need a curler for straight lashes
MERIT Clean Lash Lengthening Mascara
- Soft, natural definition that is hard to mess up
- Minimal clumping with good separation
- Easy, gentle removal
- Not a high-drama volume formula
- May need extra coats for very dark impact
Thrive Causemetics Liquid Lash Extensions Mascara
- Excellent smudge resistance for many people
- Length-focused, defined lash look
- Removes with warm water and gentle pressure
- Can feel different if you are used to traditional mascara
- Less plush volume than creamier formulas
Buying Guide
Pro Tip: Make Clean Mascara Wear Longer With a 60-Second Prep
Start with dry lashes and clean lids. If there is leftover skincare on your lash line, even a great clean mascara can slide. After moisturizer and sunscreen, give your lids a minute to set, then lightly blot the lash line. If you wear complexion makeup, a tiny tap of translucent powder right at the lash line can make a bigger difference than switching mascaras.
Apply thinner coats than you think you need. Many cleaner formulas stay more flexible, which is lovely for comfort, but it also means heavy coats can stay tacky longer and pick up oil. Wipe excess off the wand, apply one thin coat, wait a few seconds, then add a second coat only where you need it. For extra separation, comb through with a clean spoolie while the mascara is still slightly damp.
Remove gently, especially if you are chasing lash growth. At night, let your remover do the work. Hold a warm, damp cotton pad on each eye for several seconds before wiping down. For tubing formulas, use warm water and gentle pressure to slide off the tubes instead of rubbing, since friction is what makes lashes feel sparse over time.
💡 Editor’s Final Thoughts
Final Verdict: If you want one clean mascara that does a little bit of everything, Ilia Limitless Lash Mascara is the most reliable all-around pick for lift, definition, and day-to-day wear. If smudging is your nonnegotiable issue, go straight to Thrive Causemetics Liquid Lash Extensions Mascara for a more budge-resistant finish that removes easily.
See also
If your eyes tend to feel irritated or dry, start with our best mascara for dry eyes guide, and compare it with the smudge-resistant options in best mascara for oily lids.
- Volumizing mascaras that build fast
- Mascara picks for a natural, defined look
- Mascaras that help hold a curl on straight lashes
Frequently Asked Questions ▾
What does “clean mascara” actually mean?
“Clean” is not a single regulated standard, so it usually means the brand is avoiding certain ingredients (commonly things like parabens, phthalates, and specific preservatives) and marketing the formula as more ingredient-conscious. The practical takeaway is to focus on how it wears on your eyes: if you are prone to irritation, prioritize comfortable wear and easy removal over buzzwords.
Do clean mascaras smudge more than conventional mascaras?
They can, especially if the formula stays creamy on the lashes or your lids get oily. If smudging is your main issue, a tubing formula (like Thrive) is often the easiest solution, because it tends to resist oily breakdown better and removes cleanly with warm water.
What is the best way to prevent flaking with clean mascara?
Flaking is often a layering problem, not just a formula problem. Wipe excess product off the wand before the first coat, apply thin layers, and let each coat set for a few seconds. If you like multiple coats, focus extra product at the base and mid-lash and use a light touch on the tips, since heavy buildup at the ends is where flakes usually start.
Can I use a lash primer with clean mascara?
Yes, but compatibility matters. A primer can boost volume and hold, but it can also increase clumping if the mascara is already thick. If you use primer, keep it very light, comb through once, and choose a more defining mascara (like Ilia or Merit) to top it so lashes still look separated.
How do I remove clean mascara without tugging my lashes?
For traditional formulas, use a cleansing balm or oil cleanser and let it sit on the lashes for several seconds before gently wiping downward. For tubing mascaras, use warm water and light pressure to slide the “tubes” off without rubbing. Either way, patience matters more than scrubbing.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases made through links on our site.