Best Eyebrow Gels & Tinted Gels

---

Quick Picks (4 columns max)

Pick	Why we love it	Finish & Hold	Best for
Benefit Gimme Brow+ Volumizing Brow Gel	Tiny microfiber fibers grip to hair and skin for believable fullness; smart shade range	Natural, flexible hold	Sparse brows, soft gaps, quick mornings
Anastasia Beverly Hills Tinted Brow Gel	Makeup-artist classic; tints evenly and lifts without stiffness	Satin, medium hold	Normal brows that need uniform color and shape
e.l.f. Wow Brow (Tinted)	Drugstore favorite with fibers; never gloopy; great value	Soft-matte, light–medium hold	Beginners, budget, everyday fill
NYX Thick It. Stick It! Brow Gel (Tinted)	Dense fibers add serious volume; buildable to bold	Natural-matte, medium–firm hold	Fine hairs that vanish; fuller, fluffier look

Ratings reflect a summary of owner feedback and stylist commentary.

---

Deep Dives

1) Benefit Gimme Brow+ Volumizing Eyebrow Gel

Rating: 4.8/5
Why it stands out: The tiny tapered brush and microfibers make this the easiest gel for filling soft gaps without drawing a single hair. One swipe grips existing hairs and even anchors lightly to skin for realistic fullness that doesn’t smudge mid-day. The shade range leans neutral, so it’s hard to pick a “wrong” tone.
Real-world results: Users say tails look thicker and arches look lifted in under a minute. It passes the sunglasses-on/off rub test but still removes cleanly with your usual cleanser.
Best for: Sparse brows, busy mornings, no-mirror touch-ups.
How to use: Wipe excess on the tube rim, start at the arch, then back-comb through the front for fluff. Add a second pass only where you need volume.

2) Anastasia Beverly Hills Tinted Brow Gel

Rating: 4.7/5
Why it stands out: This pro-favorite lays down even tint and subtle shine that reads like healthy hair, not makeup. The spoolie is a touch larger, which helps lift and set longer hairs while coating them tip-to-root.
Real-world results: Reviewers with medium to coarse texture love that it keeps ends from drooping by afternoon without going crunchy. It’s especially flattering on fuller brows that just need tone correction (think ashier brown vs warm).
Best for: Naturally full brows that need tidying and a unified color.
How to use: Brush up through the front, then angle out toward the tail. If your brow hairs are long, finish with a light upward press to seal the curve.

3) e.l.f. Wow Brow (Tinted)

Rating: 4.6/5
Why it stands out: Budget gem with fibers and a small precision brush that’s friendly for beginners. It defines individual hairs and soft gaps without clumps, and the texture stays slightly pliable so you can reposition.
Real-world results: Owners report believable volume on fine hair and no flaking, even on dry skin. Shades skew neutral-cool (great for avoiding orange).
Best for: Everyday soft fill, first brow gel, or a low-cost backup for your bag.
How to use: Feather through in short strokes; let set for 20–30 seconds, then do a second micro-coat only where you want extra presence.

4) NYX Thick It. Stick It! Brow Gel (Tinted)

Rating: 4.6/5
Why it stands out: If your brow hairs are ultra-fine or naturally light, this has the densest fibers in the group, so you see visible thickening in one pass. Finish dries natural-matte and stays put on humid days.
Real-world results: Users love the “fluffy but defined” look—like you have more hairs than you do. It resists shine on oilier skin better than most drugstore gels.
Best for: Thin, barely-there brows; anyone chasing the fuller, brushed-up effect.
How to use: Remove excess from the brush, start at mid-brow, then flick toward the front so the most product isn’t dumped at the inner corner. Let dry fully before a second layer.

---

How to Choose (quick guide)

• Sparse or fine hairs: Look for fibers (Benefit, e.l.f., NYX).
• Coarse/wiry hairs: A slightly larger brush and medium hold helps lift + set (Anastasia).
• Oily skin or humid climate: Natural-matte finishes and medium–firm hold wear cleaner (NYX).
• Undertone tips: If your hair has ash tones, choose neutral-cool. If warm highlights peek through, choose neutral-warm, not orange.

Application pro tip: For the most believable density, deposit at the middle and tail first, then use what’s left on the brush at the front. Finish by combing up, then out for a lifted eye look.

---

See Also (internal links, woven naturally)

If you want razor-sharp edges to pair with your new gel, start with Best Drugstore Eyebrow Pencil —it’s the quickest way to sketch a soft baseline before you comb color through. For the rest of your eye routine, our Best Mascara for Sensitive Eyes plays nicely with gels that can sometimes flake, and Best Eyeliner for Older Women rounds out a no-tug, all-day eye that won’t migrate.

On complexion days when you keep brows minimal, Best Drugstore Powder Foundations is a smart, shine-controlling base that doesn’t cling around brow hairs. And when you’re wiping it all away, Best Makeup Remover Wipes are the lazy-night solution that won’t leave the brow area tight or crispy. Link these five into your routine and you’ve got an easy, polished face that holds up from school drop-off to dinner.

---

FAQ

Clear gel or tinted?
Tinted adds soft color and can fill gaps fast. Clear is great if your brows are full but unruly or you already penciled/powdered.

Will gels cause flakes?
Good ones shouldn’t. Flakes usually come from over-brushing after the gel has set. Apply, shape, then leave it.

How do I keep it from looking crunchy?
Wipe excess from the brush, use short strokes, and avoid multiple heavy layers. If you overdid it, comb through with a clean spoolie while it’s still damp.

What about gray or silver hair?
Choose a cool taupe or soft gray-brown—not black. The goal is soft definition, not contrast.

Can I use brow gel with serums (like growth treatments)?
Yes. Let the serum dry first, then gel. At night, skip gel so the serum stays in contact.

---

Affiliate Disclosure: If you purchase through links on our site, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.