Resets sensitive under-eyes with lightweight, soothing hydration that won't sting or pill under concealer.
We may earn a small referral fee
Pregnancy can make your under-eyes look tired fast, and the wrong formula can sting or pill under concealer. These eye creams keep things simple, soothing, and effective for daily use.
In-depth Reviews
La Roche-Posay Toleriane Dermallergo Eye Cream
- Very low-sting, comfortable wear even on reactive skin
- Plays nicely with concealer and sunscreen (minimal pilling)
- Calms the look of dryness and irritation quickly
- Not the fastest fix for pronounced puffiness
- Price can feel high for an eye-specific product
CeraVe Eye Repair Cream
- Reliable hydration that reduces dry, crepey-looking texture
- Works well under makeup for most skin types
- Great value for daily, twice-a-day use
- May feel a touch rich for very oily eyelids
- Dark-circle results are subtle and gradual
Biossance Squalane + Marine Algae Eye Cream
- Deeply hydrating feel that visibly softens dry lines
- Comfortable for overnight use without feeling heavy
- Helps concealer sit smoother on very dry skin
- Can feel too dewy for people who prefer a dry finish
- Not targeted for significant morning puffiness
The Ordinary Caffeine Solution 5% + EGCG
- Fast-drying layer that works well in the morning rush
- Helps reduce the look of puffiness for many users
- Layers easily under richer creams if you need more moisture
- Can feel slightly drying if used alone on very dry skin
- Dropper format is not everyone’s favorite for eye-area use
First Aid Beauty Eye Duty Niacinamide Brightening Cream
- Noticeably brightens the look of darkness, especially with makeup
- Hydrates without feeling greasy or sticky
- Easy to use in thin layers (less chance of pilling)
- Tint may not suit every skin tone or preference
- If you dislike any pigment in skincare, this may not be for you
Buying Guide
What We Wish More People Knew: “Pregnancy-Safe” Is About Ingredients, Not Labels
Most eye creams are not marketed for pregnancy, so the practical approach is learning the common “avoid” ingredients, then choosing a formula that fits your skin’s current sensitivity. Many people skip topical retinoids (retinol, retinal, retinyl palmitate) during pregnancy, and the eye area is a particularly common place those show up. If your skin is also more reactive than usual, fragrance and essential oils are frequent culprits for stinging, redness, or watery eyes.
To keep the routine simple, aim for one “base” eye product that hydrates and supports your barrier (ceramides, glycerin, hyaluronic acid, peptides), then add one targeted layer only if you truly need it. For example, use a caffeine serum just in the morning for puffiness, or a niacinamide or vitamin C option at night if darkness is your main concern. Adding multiple actives at once often backfires around the eyes and can make dryness and makeup creasing worse.
Finally, application matters more than most people think. Use a tiny amount, tap gently, and keep it on the orbital bone so product does not migrate into the eye. If you suddenly develop bumps, irritation, or persistent tearing, pause new products for a week, then reintroduce one at a time. When in doubt, bring the ingredient list to your prenatal provider, especially if you have eczema, ocular rosacea, or a history of contact dermatitis.
💡 Editor’s Final Thoughts
Final Verdict: La Roche-Posay Toleriane Dermallergo Eye Cream is the best overall pick because it is reliably gentle, layers well under makeup, and supports a calmer, less reactive eye area when your skin feels unpredictable. If you want the best value for everyday hydration, CeraVe Eye Repair Cream is the easy, low-drama choice that still makes a real difference in dryness.
See also
For gentle firming without harsh actives, start with our best eye cream with peptides, and pair it with our best eye cream with vitamin C if brightening is your top priority.
- Eye creams that actually help puffiness and bags
- Top eye cream picks for very dry skin
- Check out our drugstore eye cream picks
Frequently Asked Questions ▾
What ingredients should I avoid in eye creams during pregnancy?
The big one most people skip during pregnancy is topical retinoids (like retinol, retinal, and retinyl palmitate). Many also choose to avoid hydroquinone and strong leave-on exfoliating acids close to the eye area, since that skin is thin and more prone to irritation. If you are sensitive, watch for heavy fragrance and essential oils, which can sting and trigger watery eyes. When in doubt, bring your exact product and ingredient list to your OB-GYN or dermatologist for personalized guidance.
Are vitamin C and niacinamide okay to use around the eyes while pregnant?
For most people, vitamin C and niacinamide are widely used in pregnancy-friendly routines because they are not retinoids and they support brighter-looking, more even-toned skin. Around the eyes, the bigger issue is tolerance: vitamin C can tingle if your barrier is stressed, and niacinamide can feel warm on very reactive skin if you layer too many actives. Start with a small amount every other night, keep it on the orbital bone (not right up on the lash line), and follow with a bland moisturizer if you feel any tightness.
Why do dark circles and puffiness feel worse during pregnancy, and what actually helps?
Pregnancy can change sleep, fluid retention, and circulation, so under-eyes may look puffier in the morning and more shadowed by midday. An eye product cannot fix true hollowness or genetics, but you can make a visible difference in how rested you look. Caffeine formulas tend to help most with morning puffiness, especially if you store them in a cool place and apply with a light tapping motion. For darkness, look for hydration plus gentle brighteners (like niacinamide or vitamin C) and consider a peach-toned formula that improves the look immediately under makeup.
How do I apply eye cream so it doesn’t sting, pill, or cause milia?
Use less than you think, about a rice-grain amount per eye is usually enough. Warm it between ring fingers, then tap along the orbital bone (under the eye and at the outer corner), letting it migrate naturally rather than rubbing it up to the lashes. If your concealer pills, give the eye product a full minute to settle, then apply makeup in thin layers and avoid stacking multiple silicone-heavy products. If you are prone to milia, choose lighter textures and avoid thick balms right under the lower lash line.
Should I stop my retinol eye cream if I’m trying to conceive or breastfeeding?
Many people choose to stop topical retinoids while trying to conceive and throughout pregnancy, and some continue avoiding them while breastfeeding as an extra-cautious approach. Because personal medical history matters, the safest move is to ask your clinician what they recommend for your specific situation and product. If you are swapping out retinol, peptides, ceramides, hyaluronic acid, and niacinamide are common alternatives for a smoother-looking, better-hydrated eye area. The biggest “win” during this season is consistency with gentle hydration and daily sunscreen on the surrounding skin.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases made through links on our site.