Plumps and brightens the under-eye without heaviness — works best when you apply a very thin layer and let it set.
We may earn a small referral fee
You want an eye cream that brightens and smooths without animal-derived ingredients or stingy fragrances. These vegan picks are the ones worth buying, whether you need quick morning depuffing or a serious nighttime line-smoother.
In-depth Reviews
Biossance Squalane + Marine Algae Eye Cream
- Reliable all-day hydration without feeling heavy
- Plays well under makeup when applied thinly
- Softens the look of dehydration lines fast
- Jar packaging is less ideal for people who prefer pumps
- Not the strongest option if your main goal is firming
Glow Recipe Avocado Melt Retinol Eye Sleeping Mask
- Noticeably smoothing by morning when used at night
- Great for dry under-eyes that look tired and textured
- Feels plush without sliding into the eyes
- Can be too much for very oily skin in humid climates
- Retinol-style products may require a slow ramp-up
Youth To The People Superberry Dream Eye Cream
- Lightweight but still moisturizing enough for daytime
- Helps the under-eye look more refreshed and less dull
- Layers easily with sunscreen and concealer
- May not be rich enough for very dry, mature under-eyes
- If puffiness is your main issue, a caffeine gel may work faster
The INKEY List Caffeine Eye Cream
- Works well for morning puffiness with consistent use
- Light texture that doesn’t fight concealer
- Easy to use daily without feeling greasy
- Not rich enough if dryness is your primary issue
- Results are more “subtle improvement” than dramatic change
Pacifica Vegan Collagen Recovery Eye Cream
- Comforting moisture for dry under-eyes on a budget
- Good texture for daily use, especially in cooler months
- Pairs well with simple routines
- Can feel heavy for very oily skin types
- Not a targeted option for stubborn dark circles
Buying Guide
Pro Tip: Get Better Results With the “Thin Layer, Long Wait” Method
Most eye-cream disappointment is really an application problem. Use a very thin layer, then give it time to set before you move on to sunscreen or concealer. If you apply too much, the product stays mobile and can creep into the eye, causing watering, puffiness, or that annoying makeup breakdown by lunchtime.
For daytime, press (don’t rub) from the inner under-eye outward, staying on the orbital bone. Then wait at least 60 seconds before makeup. If your concealer pills, it’s usually because either the eye product wasn’t absorbed yet or you layered too many slippery steps. One eye product plus one sunscreen is usually the sweet spot.
At night, you can go slightly richer, but keep it strategic. If you wake up puffy, you’re likely applying too close to the lash line or using too heavy a layer. Place the product a bit lower on the under-eye and at the outer corner, then let body heat do the work. Consistency beats intensity here: a small amount used most nights will usually outperform a thick layer used once in a while.
💡 Editor’s Final Thoughts
Final verdict: If you want one vegan eye cream that covers the most bases, Biossance Squalane + Marine Algae Eye Cream is the best overall pick for comfortable hydration and a noticeably smoother look under makeup. For a stronger overnight approach to fine lines, the Glow Recipe Avocado Melt Retinol Eye Sleeping Mask is the most purposeful second choice.
See also
If dark circles are your top concern, start with our guide to what actually helps dark circles and then compare line-smoothing options in this roundup for wrinkles and crow’s feet.
- Best anti-ageing creams face-off (2025)
- SkinMedica TNS Recovery Complex review (what to know before you splurge)
- Facial serums under $25 that pull their weight
Frequently Asked Questions ▾
What makes an eye cream “vegan” (and how is that different from cruelty-free)?
Vegan means the formula is made without animal-derived ingredients (common ones in skincare include beeswax, lanolin, collagen, elastin, and carmine). Cruelty-free means the brand does not test the finished product or ingredients on animals. The two terms are not the same, so if you want both, look for clear vegan labeling plus a cruelty-free commitment from the brand. If your eyes are sensitive, also scan for common irritants like strong fragrance and high-alcohol formulas, even if the product is vegan.
Can vegan eye cream actually help dark circles?
Sometimes, but it depends on what kind of dark circles you have. If yours look blue or purple and change with sleep, stress, or allergies, you will usually get the best payoff from hydration plus de-puffing ingredients (caffeine, soothing humectants, and a lightweight texture that layers well under sunscreen and concealer). If your circles are more brown or gray-brown, topical brighteners can help over time, but genetics and facial structure often play a big role. In that case, aim for steady improvement, not an overnight erase.
How much eye cream should I use, and where exactly do I put it?
Use a very small amount for both eyes, then add more only if your under-eye still feels dry after a minute. Dot it along the orbital bone (the “rim” around the eye), then gently press or tap it in rather than rubbing. Keep richer creams slightly lower on the under-eye if you tend to get milia or clogged bumps, and avoid applying too close to the lash line at night, since products can migrate while you sleep and cause morning puffiness or watering.
Is a retinol eye cream safe if I have sensitive eyes?
It can be, but you need to introduce it like a prescription: slowly and strategically. Start with a night-only product a couple nights per week, and do not combine it on the same night with other strong actives that can increase irritation. If you are prone to dryness, try applying a thin layer of a plain moisturizer first, then your retinol eye product on top to buffer it. If you get burning, flaking, or watery eyes that last into the next day, back off frequency or switch to a peptide-rich cream instead.
Do I really need a separate eye cream, or can I use my face moisturizer?
You can often use a gentle face moisturizer around the eyes, especially if your main issue is simple dryness and your moisturizer is fragrance-free and non-stinging. A dedicated eye cream earns its keep when you want a specific texture (fast-absorbing gel for morning puffiness, richer balm for nighttime dryness) or targeted ingredients that play nicely under makeup. If concealer tends to crease, pill, or break apart, swapping to a smoother eye-specific formula can make a bigger difference than changing concealer.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases made through links on our site.